Turning Tenkara

Andy Collings transitions from sceptic to full convert

Subscriber Access

Current FlyLife Subscribers can log in to access Magazine View.

To access Magazine View, back issues & more, subscribe to FlyLife today.

Subscribe
Reading View

There is always that one guy at a party. Everybody is smiling, the conversation is flowing and he drops the line, ‘I’m into Tenkara fishing actually.’ In a crowded room of the most seasoned fly fishers this would definitely provoke some awkwardness, but in a room of general public it is full panic mode engaged: ‘Oh no, he’s actually going to start explaining what that is to me, isn’t he?’

As once long ago in Damascus, this story follows a conversion theme — I was one of those people backing away slowly whenever Tenkara came up. I thought it was nerdy, silly and just a pretty good way of not catching fish that could easily be caught with ‘normal gear’.

As a trout guide, I have come across Tenkara zealots who might raise the idea with a glint in their eye and fingers twitching on their artisanal hemp bag. I always managed to shut those conversations down with the very firmly underscored: WE WILL BE USING A 9-FOOT 5-WEIGHT TODAY! That was until I met David, an Irish angler.

We had a good day’s fishing on a tiny spring creek in North East Tasmania with a couple of things getting in the way: late summer long grass causing frustrating hang-ups, and fussy fish that were ignoring presentations with even the tiniest bit of micro drag. Plus these fish were spooking from the merest hint of fly line on water, however delicately landed.

All these issues, David explained, would not be a concern with a Tenkara rod. Drag free drifts are easy to obtain since all of the system, minus fly and tippet, is above water. Made sense. He completed my conversion by kindly gifting me a Tenkara rod. Be rude not to then, eh?

In this article I will tell the story of my full conversion but also attempt to make a case for why you should try Tenkara, and present the case beyond the ‘just cos’ to showing how it can improve your angling skills in many ways.

ONE FLY

The rod arrived with only days left of the season. I needed to move quickly but there was one other thing. I thought Tenkara flies looked curiously cool, but I’d never fished a reverse hackle fly before and just didn’t fancy tying one. Looking at some images, I changed my mind a little — reminiscent of a crane fly, water boatman or spider perhaps? Some of these patterns did look really cool!

I know you can (and I do occasionally) just use any regular dry or nymph with Tenkara, but I figured in for a penny in for a pound. I would attempt to fish with a Tenkara or ‘Kebari’ style fly and keep to one pattern ‘to rule them all’. I use quotes to illustrate my complete and utter lack of knowledge in the history and customs of Tenkara, and to try and avoid any cultural appropriation.

So, that being said, I found a curved shrimp/scud hook — Kamasan B100 in size 12 — tied a ribbed body of pheasant tail, a reverse grizzly hen’s hackle and a little collar of Veniard peacock dub (olive). I called it the PTK — Pheasant Tail Kebari. I hoped it would become functional as an allrounder and that a trout may, in a pinch, try to eat this thing. It shared the materials I use for my go-to Pheasant Tail Nymph pattern, so that was giving me a little confidence.

FIRST SESSION

I chose the serendipitous approach to the first fishing session — the same Creek that David and I had fished. On approaching the water I spotted a fish nymphing over shin-deep sand. I snuck up close, into ‘Tenkara range’ (NEWSFLASH: this is the same spot that you should, could or would be in for almost all ‘normal’ fishing. More on that in a bit). The first cast went in, an easy reach over that pesky long grass, and as the rod whistled through the air, I thought to myself: ‘Wait, I don’t actually know how to do this!’

There is a little trick to it, but I got it long after the fish had got over waiting. I realised that with a short, fast, vertical and almost wristy back-lift, followed by a deliberate point at the target, I was able to cast with respectable distance and accuracy. The entire casting stroke is very short, maybe 20 degrees each side of the vertical. Speed, as opposed to brute force from the angler, is key.

Later I found the index finger is best pointed fully extended up the back of the rod. This grip can move from end of butt to up the rod proper, to adjust for distance. Trying out bow-and-arrow casting I soon realised that you can zing the whole lot out, as if from a cannon.

Let’s do the maths: 12 feet of rod, 10 feet of level line and 4 feet of tippet — a whopping 26-foot cast, BOOM! Hold the rod at the very butt end and reach your arm out like Mr Tickle and you might even hit 30. There is no open, 30-foot long pool on that whole creek, and not that many in the whole of North East Tasmania! The whole ‘no fly line and reel’ thing is totally fine.

Back on the river and my learning on the job was rewarded, the PTK was dead-drifted along an undercut bank with a bubble line adjacent. There had to be a fish in there… a swirl… a quick strike and I was on!

The first thing I noticed is the energy that a Tenkara rod gives back when it’s loading up on a fish — it is awesome! There’s a zippy high-pitched whistling noise at the moment of hook-set, a high beat oscillation through the rod and the very real sense that all of this system is being stretched close to its limits. It all lends to a highly addictive and satisfyingly direct connection to the fish.

If this is the moment we all chase, that fleeting, visceral moment of everything coming together, then I had stumbled on a method which accentuated it in a unique way. From that first day, I was fully in — Hook, level line and Kebari. (That’s one of my best Tenkara jokes I keep for parties).

I want to stress the things I’m loving about Tenkara fishing, why you should definitely try it and where it can even be advantageous or certainly of no hindrance. But first I should mention something I have found.

FISH SIZE

Even the most modest of trout is a challenge to play and land. The upper limit I think for my rod, particularly in fast flowing water, is around a 30-cm/12-inch fish. I have unfortunately hooked and left the fly in a trout larger than that. A fat and fit brown snapped the fly as it landed, ran quickly upstream and I was instantly caught off guard. With the rod fully bent over backwards and stretched to its limits I simply ran out of space to follow. Before I could jump in the stream to allow some play, PING.

I reacted far too ponderously, and it felt pretty poor. In fact it’s the only time in this article I’ll say it — a reel and even a length of fly line to let run through the fingers would have been ideal. Therefore it’s good to think tactically and plan an advance escape-route for the fight. Can you follow the fish? Include in your calculations the rod path — overhead branches or bankside scrub needs to be negotiated.

Also I’ve learned to be aware of silly casts to fish I know are over a log, say, or in heavy cover where all the aforementioned ‘landing plans’ are mitigated. Since the fight can be tricky with even reasonably small trout, do everything to protect them by bringing a net, crushing barbs and handling with the utmost care.

Of course, there are big fish Tenkara rods and it would pay to scale rod use to a range of water you know well and have a good idea of likely fish size ranges. I’m emphasising here in case you missed it that it is necessary, for ethical reasons, to purchase several Tenkara rods.

With that season almost over I only managed one more trip, to a fast flowing stream in North East Tasmania, of which there are several that cross the Tasman Highway. It was very good fun, with many eager fish smashing the PTK. My take home from that was it’s really a great all-round fly. I caught both rising and nymphing fish that day. I sight-fished, picked off rises and raised some unseen. The fly got hit right on touchdown like a dry. If run through a shallow riffle with fish sitting on the bottom it got down far enough to interest them. Also, a Kebari style fly can be gently pulsed to energise a strike — this has worked for me in still pockets.

EASY SKILLS

Technically speaking all the skills of Tenkara are easy — as I have described, it can be picked up in one trip as long as you have some angling experience. Importantly, I believe it will sharpen up your overall fly-fishing game, especially in tactical and positional choices, something that I hold in high priority and always strive to improve upon.

Stealth is obviously key in any close-range fly fishing and ‘first time, every time’ casts are of course preferable. I do see a lot of people that might usually fish ‘big’ water, where this is part of their game that is lacking. Tenkara fishing puts you ultra-close with the challenge of being quiet, concealing yourself from the fish, using cover and putting only the fly and minimal tippet in its eyeline. All skills which are particularly useful and easily transferable.

Another bonus: when you approach a fish with only one fly pattern, it’s a wonderful thing not to be grinding the gears while staring at the bewildering choice of your personal fly-industrial complex. Whether you are a straight-line nymphing devotee or dry fly purist, I think Tenkara will help you by improving presentation, tactics and stealth.

READY TO GO

The beauty of Northern Tasmania where I live is just how much great Tenkara water there is. But I bet you have access to areas like that too. Step-over spring creeks? Bouldery, fast flowing pocket water? Overgrown streams teeming with hungry trout if only you can hack your way to the bin-lid sized patches of open water? You’re in.

I’m 45 minutes away from a wide variety like this, which brings me to the crux of why I have been loving Tenkara so, so much. When I’m not working, I’m on school run duties. Additional errands and simply life getting in the way provides me with short windows to fish. Minimalism equals time saved. Taking the decision out of whether to fish the dry, nymph or wet saves in procrastination and packing time. Do I take the 5-weight, the 4-weight, the nymphing rod or the twig rod? The Tenkara rod just sits in its spot in the car ready-rigged and takes a few seconds to set up on-water.

There are just two knots to tie, once your level line is permanently affixed and a solid ring attached. Carrying it to the stream folded down is so much easier and quicker compared with an 8- or 9-foot fly rod. A couple of PTK’s are the only true essential to bring. I have a small tin that holds a dozen or so stowed with the rod, but they are always at hand.

No need for bulky backpacks or vests loaded with multiple fly boxes, rotary tippet holders, zingers or a plethora of squeezy tubes and tubs. All I take is a spool of tippet, nippers, forceps and perhaps just a little smugness packed into my artisanal man-bag. Try it out! I really need someone to talk to at parties.

SUBSCRIBE TO FLYLIFE NEWS

Privacy Preference Center