The Ngongotaha Legacy

James Fuller visits New Zealand’s last great trout hatchery

Subscriber Access

Current FlyLife Subscribers can log in to access Magazine View.

To access Magazine View, back issues & more, subscribe to FlyLife today.

Subscribe
Reading View

If you’ve ever locked horns with an 8-pound bruiser at Okataina beach in the dead of night, heard your reel sing on opening morning at the Ohau Channel, feasted on fat, orange-fleshed Rotoiti fish, or netted trout beneath Tarawera’s majestic mountainsides, then you should be doffing your cap to Mark Sherburn’s Ngongotaha¯ Hatchery team.

Tucked away at the base of Mt Ngongotaha¯, this humble facility has quietly sustained the iconic Rotorua trout fishery for over a century. It’s not glamourous work, nor is it particularly well-funded, but it is critical.

‘There’s often a fair bit of Kiwi No.8 wire mentality about the operation,’ says Mark, as the hatchery manager sends scoopfuls of pellets arcing into a powder-blue Bay of Plenty sky. A frothing feeding frenzy erupts each time they hit the water. ‘We don’t have a lot of money, so we produce these fish in a very cost-competitive way,’ adds the man who has led hatchery operations for over 20 years.

Ngongotaha¯ is the North Island’s last operational trout hatchery and one of only three in the country. It operates without pumps, gravity-fed from the pristine Waimataa Stream, which emerges from fractured volcanic rock on the hillside above, a natural spring of life which once doubled as the nearby Ngongotaha¯ village’s water supply. That volcanic heritage gives the area’s lakes their unique character, and their challenges.

Limited or unsuitable spawning streams, coupled with tens of thousands of angler visits annually (making it one of New Zealand’s most heavily fished regions) mean the Rotorua lakes need stocking. The hatchery holds the fishery together.

‘Lake Tarawera, 70% of fish caught are hatchery fish,’ says Mark. ‘So if someone catches three, two are ours. Take that away, and you’ve got one fish. Maybe none. If we weren’t able to produce fish for even one year, the knock-on impact would be enormous, for anglers, licence holders, and the local economy. Most streams and rivers don’t need restocking anymore but the lakes do. Without us, the Rotorua fishery would collapse.’

In an age where many hatcheries have shut their doors, Ngongotaha¯ survives because it’s essential. It’s also remarkably efficient. Everything, from oxygen tanks to fish feed, is sourced with an eye on cost. ‘We just swapped oxygen suppliers because we found a better deal,’ notes Mark.

MEANT TO BE

Mark Sherburn is a man who lives and breathes trout. ‘I’ve been fanatical about them since I was very small,’ he says. ‘I still sit and watch the young fish while I’m having lunch.’

His journey started in Hawke’s Bay, disappearing for hours as a child into the Maraetotara Stream, catching eels and trout, fascinated by the insects that formed the underwater food chain. After a stint in Tasmania guiding and tying flies, and nearly two decades at Kilwell in rod design, Mark eventually found himself exactly where he was meant to be. Though his calling does come with its challenges.

‘Every angler knows just how to run a hatchery,’ he adds with a wry smile. ‘I’m pretty used to being told how wide of the mark I am and what I should and shouldn’t be doing. Occupational hazard. People ask why I’m not breeding with 5kg fish. I say, ‘Well, there aren’t any.’ They reply, ‘There you go, that’s your problem!’

A YEAR IN THE LIFE

The hatchery calendar follows nature’s rhythms. April 1 marks the start of the breeding cycle, when the team begins five months of trapping brood fish at Lake Tarawera’s Te Wairoa Trap. Fish are measured, fin-clipped, and data logged to inform a 50-year-long data set, then selected for breeding. Only the best make the cut. ‘We mostly breed with three-year-olds,’ Mark says. ‘It’s nothing more complicated than what a farmer does with his best bulls or rams.’

From May through winter, the team is busy hatching, feeding, and bringing the young fish on. Once alevins have consumed their yolk sacs and begin to ‘swim up’, they’re hand-fed powdered pellets, the start of a diet that transitions through eight different pellet sizes and consumes 12 to 15 tonnes of feed a year.

By spring of the following year, the fingerlings have reached 18cm, the ideal size for lake release. ‘That’s when they can get onto the smelt straight away,’ he says, referencing the small baitfish that spawn in spring and autumn. The release timings have been trialled and tested over years. ‘We even tried monthly releases one year to see what worked best. It confirmed what we thought, spring and autumn liberations are best.’

Each fish spends about six months in indoor tanks and six in outdoor ponds, cared for until they’re ready to take their place in the wild. By the New Year, they’re counted and moved outdoors, and the process starts again.

TE WAIROA TRAP

Lake Tarawera’s Te Wairoa Trap is the pulse of the breeding programme. Located near the mouth of the cold, clear Te Wairoa stream that flows from the lake, it allows fisheries scientists to monitor the health of the population and collect the best brood fish.

It’s familiar work for Mark but it’s not always pleasant, he tells me as we stand knee deep on a crisp morning netting the coloured-up rainbows which have had their spawning runs upstream temporarily interrupted by the trap.

One particularly grim day two years ago, a cold southerly blew in and heavy rain filled the stream, prompting a surge of running fish. Mark stood waist-deep in freezing water, wind howling through the trees, measuring fish after fish. ‘We had 150 come through in one day. I’d certainly had enough by the finish.’

Fish in the 5.5–6lb range are typical, and each one is measured, weighed and assessed for quality, with only the very best making the journey back to the hatchery. There they are put in holding ponds, waiting for the perfect time for the hens to be stripped of their eggs. Once fertilised with the jack’s milt, mixed together in some very scientific ice cream tubs, the eggs are taken back to the hatchery proper, and the process is underway.

TROPHIES & TIGER TROUT

In all, 63,400 trout were released last year, with the trophy lakes of Rotoiti, Okataina and Tarawera receiving 65% (41,500) of them. Rotoiti receives 28,500 fish per year, but there were liberations at 13 lakes in total around the region. The vast majority of these fish are rainbows, with just 700 (1%) being browns.

‘Everything about the stocking is carefully considered today,’ says Mark. ‘It’s a far cry from the old acclimatisation society days when people would rock up to a waterway and tip a bucket of young trout in.’

Lake Rotoma¯ gets something a little different: tiger trout, a hybrid between a female brown and a male brook trout. Up to 1,000 tiger trout are released into Rotoma¯ each year, the only lake in New Zealand where they’re permitted.

‘The anglers love them but they’re quite hard to produce,’ Mark says. ‘We start with a lot of eggs, but not many make it.’

STEEPED IN HISTORY

With records once held at the hatchery unfortunately having been lost, the precise opening date of the first hatchery on this site is a little murky.

The major expanded hatchery facility which now stands here, was opened by the Minister of Internal Affairs, the Hon. W. E. Parry, on 3 September, 1938. It was the first to be run by the Government. The Auckland Weekly News of the day reported Mr. Parry’s speech, stating the hatchery had been found necessary to meet the growing needs of the area’s children for a yearly supply of fish. Mr Parry also referenced the ‘1905 hatchery’ when comparing the updated facility’s ability to hold 2,400,000 ova, compared to the 800,000 ova of its predecessor.

A date of the early 1900s is most likely, but in the boomtime era of the acclimatisation societies, which were enthusiastically introducing sporting species of fur, feather and fin across New Zealand, it may have been earlier. Many boutique hatcheries sprang up during the period and the NZ Herald in August 1897, reporting on a sizeable run of spawning fish heading up the Ngongotaha¯ and Umurua streams noted, as an aside, ‘the little hatchery erected here is also yielding satisfactory results.’

THE EARLY INNOVATOR

We’re still able to stretch back 60 years into the hatchery’s bygone days through the memories of three long-serving managers — Len Newman, Debbie Stewart and Mark Sherburn.

Len arrived in 1965 and ushered in nearly two decades of transformation. ‘It was a pretty basic operation in the beginning, where we used to rear and raise the trout on minced liver. We’d mix beef livers, from the freezing works in Auckland, with other ingredients such as fish and meat meal and vitamins when we could get them, in a concrete mixer of all things, each morning. It wasn’t a very pleasant job.’

But Len was a man of ideas, introducing New Zealand’s first dry salmonid diet, sourcing it from a mill in Tauranga after studying hatcheries in the United States. That not only improved the quality of fish but drastically reduced effluent runoff into the Ngongotaha¯ Stream.

He also spearheaded the ‘Kids’ Fish Out’ days, a popular community initiative still going strong today; and pushed for better fish transport, evolving from basic trailer tanks to multi-compartment trucks that could carry fish longer distances. Len even once brought in trout from the remote Ruakituri River by military helicopter, hoping their wild genetics would hold in other rivers. They didn’t, but that spirit of experimentation shaped the hatchery’s philosophy.

Len, now in his late 80s and living in Westport on the South Island, recalls his time at Ngongotaha¯ with fondness.

‘It was very special. I was able to use my initiative to turn the hatchery into something which was viable and useful. When you consider what the Rotorua fishery means to the town, to families, to tourism, it really starts to add up. The hatchery underpins all of that.’

THE PIONEER

In 1987, Debbie Stewart became one of the first women in New Zealand to manage a trout hatchery. In her 16 years in charge she brought ever greater scientific precision to the facility.

In the early 80s, Peter Mylchreest had undertaken a series of experimental fisheries management projects in the Rotorua Lakes to enhance the performance of hatchery-reared rainbow trout. These projects were aimed at improving trout size, quality, and angler returns by investigating factors such as spawning timing, age-at-maturity, liberation methods, and selective breeding. They became known as the ‘Big Fish Programme’.

Debbie played a key role in formalising this programme, focusing on selecting trout that matured later, giving them time to grow to trophy sizes before spawning. It worked.

‘Four years after we started, later-maturing fish began turning up in anglers’ catches regularly. Suddenly, what was once extraordinary became normal,’ she says. ‘Fly fishers on Rotoiti and Tarawera would return with their limit bags, 8 fish, averaging 10lb each, and call it a pretty average day.’ That success cemented Rotorua’s reputation as an international trout destination.

Today, the legacy of the Big Fish Programme continues to influence fisheries management practices in the region. The principles of selective breeding and sustainable stocking remain integral to maintaining healthy and abundant trout populations in the Rotorua lakes.

Tarawera doesn’t produce the huge trophy trout it once did and present-day manager Mark says the reasons are varied.

‘There are cycles in nature, the lakes were in a high productivity phase, there was no jigging or downriggers then, so there was more survival of the bigger fish. There are environmental, and other, factors beyond our control. Usually it’s about availability of food but it’s a complex picture. Genetics don’t change and we’re still breeding with the best fish so there are other factors at play.’

THE LEGACY FLOWS ON

Whilst there might not be the same proliferation of trophies around today, they haven’t disappeared. Double figure rainbows are taken from Okataina and Rotoiti every year, and a 10lb fish was caught in Tarawera’s Te Wairoa Trap this winter. The Rotorua fishery remains one of the best in the world. Those who fish it know this only too well.

As you stroll around the picturesque hatchery grounds, which are open to the public, you’re walking through a very special piece of New Zealand trout angling history. These grounds and buildings double as Fish & Game’s Eastern Region headquarters. What they do here on such a constrained budget, and the world-class angling it ultimately delivers, is nothing short of remarkable.

The operations are funded solely through licence holders, so next time you’re sliding towards a good old-fashioned ‘licence fees moan’, maybe stop for a quick think. The Ngongotaha¯ Hatchery, in whatever guise, has provided more than a century of stellar service to fishers young and old, kiwi or overseas. It’s easy to take these things for granted until they’re gone.

For Mark’s part, his commitment remains unwavering, and he retains a healthy sense of humour about the expectations placed upon him.

‘Anglers are easy to look after because they know what they want. They want big fish and lots of fish. Piece of cake,’ he laughs.

SUBSCRIBE TO FLYLIFE NEWS

Privacy Preference Center