Jeff’s Black Spinner

Trout flies with Peter Watson

Subscriber Access

Current FlyLife Subscribers can log in to access Magazine View.

To access Magazine View, back issues & more, subscribe to FlyLife today.

Subscribe
Reading View

The Black Spinner is arguably the iconic dry fly for Tasmanian lakes. Sure there are duns, damselflies and a host of terrestrials that provide just as much, if not more surface action. But when thinking about the lakes while stuck at our desks or shivering in winter, it is the trout chasing black spinners that first come to mind.

While many of our regular patterns have their roots in English or American flies, the Black Spinner appears to be an Australian innovation; one born from necessity no doubt.

Part 2 of Tony Dell’s excellent ‘A Basic Tasmanian Fly Box’ (FL#50: full version on FlyLife website) goes into some depth on the history of the Black Spinner, with Dick Wigram almost certainly being the originator, tying them up for his own use (presumably in the late 1920s). Later the pattern is also attributed to Noel Jetson, the two variations differing in tail length and possibly rib colour.

With the thread-body and ribbing imitating the mayfly spinner’s dainty features and the stiff hackle and tail fibres sitting the fly high on the surface like a hovering natural, the pattern has remained relatively unchanged since Wigram’s time.

Despite this longevity, using a Black Spinner does not guarantee a take every time, but unlike many other patterns, a refusal to a well-tied Black Spinner has come to mean your presentation wasn’t up to scratch, rather than an issue with the fly.

I’m not sure why this is the case. Perhaps it is perceived that the pattern is so close a match to the naturals that any change makes it less of a Black Spinner than you started with. Or it really is all in the presentation: spinner feeders are often taking the naturals on the wing.

Short of making your fly levitate, the best option is to land it close enough so the fish is aware of its arrival, but not so close that you spook it in the calm conditions the naturals prefer.

A recent variation to the unchangeable Black Spinner has come from FlyLife contributor Jeff Cassidy. A regular on the FlyLife Forum under his moniker of JC2, Jeff’s Black Spinner came about while staying at Miena before the 2013 Forum Gathering.

“I can’t exactly be sure when the idea came but I had been tying some simple versions, just black thread and hackle. I did have a new genetic hackle from Cookshill Fly Tying in England, and it was glossy black with fine feathers of regular width and very long.

“Just on a whim one morning before anyone else was up I decided to palmer a few Black Spinners. Initially without a varnished body, but I quickly realised a wet varnish would be much more durable. The full palmer was just like a bottle brush so I trimmed and tapered the body. I like palmered flies because they sit nicely on the water, float well and look very tasty.”

The use of a palmered body seems to have been forgotten in recent times, replaced by the predominance and ease of modern dubbing materials — in the search for improvement, new is often perceived as better. Unlike dubbing, palmered bodies produce a lighter fly, vital in a pattern required to sit as high as possible on the water, while the wrapped fibres form the impression of an outline and allow light to pass through, giving a lifelike translucence and sparkle.

Jeff prefers the TMC 101 while I’ve gone for the TMC 100BL as a barbless option. Sticking to a lighter gauge hook helps with the high floating characteristics but needs to be balanced with the potential for an encounter with a large trout.

Lay a base of thread on your selected hook and form a small bump level with the barb to help separate the tail fibres. Select half a dozen cock fibres and tie in — as you wrap back against the bump it will spread the fibres out. Tail length is purely personal: my preference is for one and a half times the shank length, which balances the fly nicely on the water.

Tie in a good quality hackle and lay an even layer of thread three quarters of the way up the shank. Coat the thread with one of the UV epoxies or some Sally Hansen’s — an older bottle that has thickened up a bit works perfectly. While the body is still wet, wrap the hackle forward in close, but not touching, turns and secure with three turns of thread.

Set the UV epoxy, or allow the varnish to dry a little. Hold the remaining hackle out of the way and trim the body short with a slight taper forward. Trim top and bottom, then the sides, before cleaning up any stray fibres. A rotary vice makes the trimming easier.

With the body trimmed, wrap the remaining hackle forward neatly and tie off. Form a small neat head, whip finish and add a drop of varnish to secure.

Jeff’s use of the one feather for both the body and hackle leads to a quick and easy tie. This pattern brought success at the Gathering and has gone on to fool trout on the Monaro and at Ebor, becoming a permanent addition to Jeff’s fly box.

Only the trout can tell if it is a better Black Spinner, so try one next time you’re out: but just be sure to get the presentation right.

For those who don’t tie their own, these and other patterns are available direct from Jeff at freshandsaltwaterflydesigns-australia.com.au

SUBSCRIBE TO FLYLIFE NEWS

Privacy Preference Center